3.5.2 Waveguide reflection: the beam on an elastic foundation

The musical saw is an example of a waveguide: a system that is long in one dimension, with a cross-section that is uniform or only slowly varying along the length. Such systems may be capable of carrying waves along the length, with behaviour in the cross-sectional plane corresponding to some kind of resonance. The musical saw is an example: the behaviour in the cross-section is like a free-free bending resonance across the width of the saw blade. To give an idea of the mathematical approach to analysing such a system, we can use a simpler waveguide. We will take a bending beam, like the one analysed in section 3.2.1, but we will give it an elastic foundation, sometimes called a Winkler foundation. Instead of the beam being free to vibrate as in the earlier calculation, we assume that it is tied to fixed ground by springs uniformly distributed along the length. This is a system often used to analyse the effect of foundations under buildings or ballast underneath railway track.

Figure 1. Sketch of a bending beam on an elastic foundation

The system is sketched in Fig. 1. We can assume a beam just like the one analysed in section 3.2.1, but with the addition of the foundation spring with a stiffness $K$ per unit length: the units of $K$ are thus N/m/m. It is easy to see that we need just one extra term in the governing equation compared to eq. (7) from section 3.2.1: this equation becomes

$$\rho A \dfrac{\partial^2 w}{\partial t^2}+EI \dfrac{\partial^4 w}{\partial x^4} + K w=0\tag{1}$$

where the term $Kw$ represents the force from the foundation springs. We are interested in solutions to this equation that are travelling waves, so try substituting

$$w(x,t) = e^{i k x} e^{i \omega t} .\tag{2}$$

Then eq. (1) requires that the wavenumber $k$ satisfies

$$k^4 = \dfrac{\rho A \omega^2 -K}{EI} . \tag{3}$$

Without the presence of $K$, eq. (3) would mean that for any value of $\omega$ we can find a real solution for $k$. In physical terms, that means that on a beam without the foundation, waves can propagate at any frequency. But with the foundation term, things are different. For frequencies satisfying

$$\omega^2 > \frac{K}{\rho A} \tag{4}$$

we can still find a real solution for $K$. But if

$$\omega^2 < \frac{K}{\rho A} \tag{5}$$

this is no longer possible. The possible solutions take the form

$$k=\frac{\pm 1 \pm i}{\sqrt{2}} \left[\dfrac{K – \rho A \omega^2 }{EI} \right]^{1/4} \tag{6}$$

so that all possible solutions decay exponentially with $x$. Such solutions are called evanescent waves. The transition frequency $\omega = \sqrt{\frac{K}{\rho A} }$, above which travelling waves first become possible, is called the waveguide cut-on frequency (or cut-off frequency, if you are thinking about scanning downwards in frequency when you encounter it).

Now imagine that the value of foundation stiffness $K$ varies slowly along the the length of the beam. We can obtain an analogue of the S-shaped saw by supposing that $K \propto x^2$. The extra stiffness is zero at $x=0$, then increases symmetrically as you move away from that point in either direction. If we drive the beam into vibration at some chosen frequency $\omega$ at $x=0$, waves will propagate outwards in both directions. But they cannot pass beyond the pair of points where $K=\rho A \omega^2$, so the vibration must be confined between these two points, just as we found in the musical saw.

Of course, the saw cannot resonate at every frequency. This mechanism of reflection is part of the story, but there is another condition necessary to create a mode like the one seen in the musical saw. This is the condition of phase closure. We can track our wave as it reflects up and down the waveguide and completes a full round trip. The phase will advance steadily as the wave propagates, and the process of reflection will involve a phase change of some kind. The condition for resonance, and the formation of a mode, is that the total change of phase after a round trip must be a multiple of $2 \pi$, so that the wave “joins up with itself”.